Hollywood is notorious for its engineering stereotypes. Some portrayals are hilariously off-base, while others hit the nail on the head.
So let’s dive into the top 10 engineering stereotypes Hollywood dishes out, and I’ll share my thoughts on their accuracy. You can have a good laugh and draw your own conclusions.
#1 Instant product or device creation
Picture this: the end of the world is looming, and the tech needed to save humanity is nowhere to be found. Yet, there’s a brilliant team of engineers ready to swoop in and save the day. They huddle together in a dimly lit room filled with random junk, tools clanging and hammers pounding, while coffee keeps flowing to fuel their energy.
Suddenly, they emerge, triumphant, with a mind-blowing invention that’s ready to roll. And all this in less than a week! These movie engineers make Elon Musk’s audacious timelines seem timid.
But hold on a second. In reality, the engineering process for new designs involves tons of work. It takes a deeply intertwined creative engineering process just to get started. The brainstorming stage alone, where a design direction is determined, can take years. Add the time needed for engineering design and development, and it’s clear that movie timelines are hilariously far-fetched.
#2 Expert in countless contrasting fields of study
Imagine an engineer, one day solving differential equations on a chalkboard, and the next thing you know, they’re:
- Playing politician
- Single-handedly designing and developing tech to combat global warming
- Reverse engineering the biological effects of global warming on humans
To call this range of expertise far-fetched would be a massive understatement. Engineers aren’t even close to being this versatile. Mastering a single engineering subject takes years, so there’s no way anyone could become an expert in numerous unrelated fields. Besides, our brains just don’t have the processing power to handle it all.
In movies, it’s common to see a single engineer wearing multiple hats, being a high-level designer by day and a global peacemaker by night.
#3 The one-person show
Picture an engineer singlehandedly doing everything from A to Z. For instance, the U.S. President orders the development of a weather-fighting device, and a lone engineer comes up with the design concept and manufactures it, without asking for any help. After all, engineers are insanely brilliant and masters of all trades, right?…
Well, I hope you caught my sarcasm.
In real life, a single engineer can’t possibly handle everything, especially when it comes to cutting-edge, high-tech devices. In reality, teams of expert engineers need to collaborate.
#4 Inventing in the garage
Decades ago, Bill Hewlett and David Packard founded HP in their garage. Since then, Hollywood has made it a trend to showcase engineers working in garages.
However, what gets lost in translation is the type of products Bill and David actually worked on. Sure, their garage served as a research lab and workshop, but their first product was an audio oscillator—not a fusion reactor!
Despite this, Hollywood has engineers building all sorts of advanced tech in their garages, which are far from state-of-the-art. They’re just your average suburban American garages.
Somehow, these garages magically house millions of dollars’ worth of advanced equipment. And let’s not forget about all the unexplained factors:
- High power requirements
- Ventilation considerations
- Cleaning and safety considerations
#5 Repairing unfamiliar tech in a jiffy
Hollywood makes it seem like having the title “engineer” means you can instantly repair anything. It’s always entertaining when the government hands an engineer an alien spacecraft. The engineer scratches their head, curiosity written all over their face, and the next thing you know, they’re knee-deep in the spacecraft, taking things apart and fiddling with screens.
Meanwhile, the engineer somehow figures out precisely how everything works, all without any documentation or manuals. Talk about wizardry!
In reality, engineers need documents to reverse-engineer unfamiliar equipment and devices, and it would take years to learn how something works without proper guidance.
Similarly, I always find it amusing when people assume I can fix everything just because I’m an engineer. Sure, I’m an engineer, but that doesn’t make me an expert in disassembling and fixing all your household gadgets!
#6 Instantly hacking into networks
The fate of the world hangs in the balance, and it’s all up to an engineer’s fingertips. We’ve all seen those action movies where an engineer intensely gazes at a blue screen while dramatic music blares in the background. Here’s how it usually goes:
The engineer coolly takes a seat, surveys the lines of code, cracks their knuckles, and dives into the hacking frenzy. Within minutes, sweat dripping from their brow, they’ve done it.
A collective sigh of relief sweeps through the anxious bystanders. The engineer has miraculously hacked into the national security system. Unbelievable, right?!
Honestly, I find it wildly amusing how this all unfolds in mere minutes, especially considering the engineer had no prior knowledge of the system. Yet somehow, all the system parameters are magically embedded in the engineer’s brain.
In reality, you’d need to spend months uncovering a network’s vulnerabilities before even making a dent in the system.
#7 Zero social skills
In many movies, engineers are portrayed as having antisocial personalities. They can’t maintain eye contact, and they speak like robots. In other words, they’re painfully awkward and seem odd.
This portrayal is one of the most powerful engineering stereotypes out there, and it has definitely tainted the public’s perception of engineers.
However, many top engineers actually have excellent social skills because they need to effectively communicate and sell their ideas. That being said, there are plenty of brilliant engineers who do lack social skills, as intelligence can sometimes be linked to Asperger’s syndrome.
So, while there’s some truth to this depiction, it’s important to remember that it doesn’t apply to all engineers. There are plenty of introverted engineers, but it’s not a one-size-fits-all stereotype.
#8 Speaking technical gibberish
In movies, you’ll often hear someone tell an engineer to speak in plain English because they’re spouting off complex jargon that leaves everyone else scratching their heads.
In real life, though, most engineers have some level of social awareness, especially the seasoned pros. They can read their audience and adjust their vocabulary accordingly, making their explanations more accessible to everyday folks.
For instance, a socially savvy engineer will simplify their language when talking to a non-engineer, while ramping up the technical terms when conversing with fellow engineers. That’s just how they tackle those gnarly technical details.
As the saying goes, if you can’t explain something in simple terms, you don’t understand it. Hollywood seems to have missed that memo.
#9 Encyclopedia of facts
According to Hollywood, engineers are walking encyclopedias. Ask them anything, and like Rain Man, they’ll spit out the answer in a heartbeat. Even detailed specs for unfamiliar equipment are seemingly at their fingertips.
What’s more, they’re portrayed as having encyclopedic knowledge across all engineering disciplines, from electrical to mechanical, nuclear to petroleum, and beyond.
I’ll admit, I’ve worked with some engineers who possess almost photographic memories. These 10x engineers could blow your mind with their near-encyclopedic knowledge. But even they don’t know everything under the sun.
Let’s face it; it’s impossible to know everything. There’s just too much information out there. Yet, this is one of the engineering stereotypes that the public clings to the most tenaciously.
#10 Ability to instantly retrofit existing designs
Picture this: we discover some alien technology on Earth, and an engineer, without missing a beat, integrates it into their own invention. Let’s not even get started on the absurdity of instantly reverse-engineering alien tech.
For instance, an engineer slaps an alien spacecraft engine into a manmade jet. Suddenly, the jet has 1000x the power and runs flawlessly. And get this, the existing jet components don’t even need to be reviewed or retrofitted. I mean, it’s just common sense that all human-made jet parts can handle alien engine tech, right?…
In reality, reverse-engineering foreign equipment without documentation can take years. And when it comes to tech that’s new to humans, we might not even understand the underlying physics at play.
Not to mention, retrofitting our tech with alien tech is an absurd proposition. Our tech would inevitably be a bottleneck because, let’s face it, if aliens can travel trillions of miles to visit us, we’d be mere dumb apes in comparison. Our tech would be child’s play.
Engineering stereotypes in Hollywood movies wrap up
I won’t lie; I do love to poke fun at Hollywood movies a bit.
But honestly, I enjoy the heck out of them, even when engineers aren’t portrayed accurately. I mean, movie producers often paint engineers as genius wizards, so no real engineer would complain, right? That is, until a family member asks them to fix a faucet and they’re stumped…
Extreme character roles are what make movies entertaining, after all. At the end of the day, it’s just a blast to pick apart engineering stereotypes and fallacies. Real-world engineers might be nothing like their movie counterparts, but that doesn’t mean we can’t enjoy a good flick with a bucket of popcorn by our side.
Which engineering stereotypes in movies rub you the wrong way the most (if any)? What’s your favorite movie featuring an engineer in a lead role?
SUBSCRIBE TO ENGINEER CALCS NEWSLETTER
Author Bio: Koosha started Engineer Calcs in 2019 to help people better understand the engineering and construction industry, and to discuss various science and engineering-related topics to make people think. He has been working in the engineering and tech industry in California for well over 15 years now and is a licensed professional electrical engineer, and also has various entrepreneurial pursuits.
Koosha has an extensive background in the design and specification of electrical systems with areas of expertise including power generation, transmission, distribution, instrumentation and controls, and water distribution and pumping as well as alternative energy (wind, solar, geothermal, and storage).
Koosha is most interested in engineering innovations, the cosmos, sports, fitness, and our history and future.